A L.A. judge ruled in favor of Frank Ocean in the defamation suit filed against the artist by his father, Calvin Cooksey.

According to TMZ, the judge ruled that Cooksey “failed to prove his son had defamed him at all.” A while back, Cooksey accused Ocean of defaming him in a social media post where the Blonde artist called him a “bigot.” The disparaging word was included in a flashback Ocean wrote about his childhood and a time when his father allegedly called a transgender waitress a “f****t.”

Ocean’s lawyers told TMZ that “it was a sad case, but we are glad that it ended in Frank’s favor and that it is over.”